Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economy. Show all posts

Thursday, July 24, 2008

Michigan's social safety net still full of holes

Our social safety net is porous. It’s a net after all, not a helmet or steel-toed boots or safety glasses. Nets have holes. Stuff slips through. People slip through. Families. Children.

This week, Michigan legislators increased state cash assistance to poor families via the Family Independence Program by $1 per month per person – a cool $12 per year. According to the Michigan League for Human Services (MLHS) this is the first across the board increase in the monthly grant in 18 years. This increase isn't going to strengthen the safety net.

“We think it’s a positive symbol that needy families receiving cash assistance are finally getting recognized in the budget, but you have to keep it in perspective because the buying power of the grant has eroded steadily over the years,’’ said Sharon Parks, president and CEO of the League, in a press release.

While it may be a positive symbol, the $1 increase is also a shameful embarrassment. Next year, a family of three will receive $36 more per year in their FIP grant. If you’ve gassed your car lately, you know $36 doesn’t buy a tankful. The buying power of the dollar continues to erode. Good thing the Family Independence Program is intended to cover rent. So how much do families that qualify actually receive?

Prior to the $1 increase, a single parent with two children received $489 a month. Unfortunately, the average rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Michigan is $627. To make ends meet recipients can also seek food stamps or federal housing subsidies. Recipients can even work. But if they earn a bit more than $300, they lose their FIP. The rules of the system push them toward independence through the holes in the safety net.

“There are plenty of families for whom this is their main income,” said Judy Putnam, communications coordinator for the MLHS. In the first quarter of 2008, 58 percent of families receiving FIP had no earned income. Children in those families do not benefit from cash income beyond the FIP grant.

The FIP assistance amounts to just 35 percent of the poverty level. In Michigan, the 2007 poverty level for a single parent with two children was $16,705.

In June 75,848 families received cash assistance from the Family Independence Program. This included about 150,000 children. Imagine the combined populations of St. Claire Shores and Farmington Hills as poor hungry children. Anybody got an extra dollar?

Water cooler ticker -- It's the economy

Ford Has $8.7 Billion Loss, Shifts Away From Trucks (Bloomberg)Analysts expect Ford's change in direction -- away from trucks to fuel efficient cars -- will be costly, with more losses ahead.

Dow Chemical reports decline in 2Q profit (Associated Press)
"Dow Chemical Co. said Thursday that despite record sales and two double-digit price increases unveiled in the second quarter, its profit for the period fell 27 percent, in large part because of sharply higher costs for energy and raw materials."

Sales of U.S. Existing Homes Fell to 10-Year Low (Bloomberg)
"Sales of previously owned U.S. homes fell in June to the lowest level in a decade, signaling tumbling real-estate prices and consumer confidence are hurting demand.

Resales dropped 2.6 percent to a lower than forecast 4.86 million annual rate from a 4.99 million pace the prior month, the National Association of Realtors said today in Washington. The median home price dropped 6.1 percent from June last year. "

National City has $1.76 bln loss on loan write-offs (UK Guardian)The Cleveland-based lender posted its fourth straight quarterly loss "hurt by soaring mortgage and real estate construction loan losses and a write-down for acquisitions."


US weekly jobless claims rise 34,000 to 406,000
(Forbes)"The number of individuals filing new claims for unemployment insurance rose to its highest level in nearly four months, while the number of individuals continuing to file claims for unemployment fell slightly in the latest survey week, the Labor Department said today."

New layoff filings jump as companies retrench (Associated Press)"The number of newly laid off people filing claims for unemployment benefits bolted past 400,000 last week as companies trimmed their work forces to cope with a slowing economy and fallout from a collapsed housing market."

Saturday, May 24, 2008

Moving on from Michigan


"If you are here for money or a signature, let me save you some time," I said preempting the pitch. "I don't do those things at the front door."

"O.K. That kinda covers it," he replied hugging a clipboard to his chest.
"So, how's it going?" I asked.
"Tonight, not so good." The ACLU activist on my front porch was slim and young in tee shirt and jeans. He could have been my son, clear-eyed, ready to change the world one front door at a time.
"What are you working on?" I asked.
"Constitutional stuff mostly," he shrugged with a smile nestled in casual stubble.
"I'd have been more pleased if you had success with the same-sex partner benefits at the Supreme Court," I said, looking past him to the blooming lupines thriving in the unseasonal cool air.
"Me, too."

Turns out, he doesn't live in Michigan, really, this activist for the progressive way forward. He was raised here in the liberal oasis of Ann Arbor, but goes to school out east and his family is relocating there as well. They just sold their house. But still he works for the cause in Michigan. He still wants to help here.

We chatted about the climate -- political, economic, cultural -- in our state, shook our heads and parted, well wishing, smiling, understanding each other a little. This summer, pursuing his ideals might turn into just another job. When it's over, he'll return to school and re-join his family's migration east. He's moving on from Michigan.

It's a creaturely thing, migration. We get attached to place, landscape, claiming our habitat, crying for its preservation and protection, associating safety with roots. But many of us notice when it's time to move on, nothing more to graze, too many predators, drought. We hear of better pasture, opportunity, maybe a place where we can gather and create and can be ourselves.

Maybe Michigan will again be a place people seek to settle. For now, she's exhaling, out with the old...

Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Taking stock of Michigan and her prospects

I started this Michigan blog project a little over a year ago, hoping to understand our state and our historic shift from a manufacturing economy to something else. Economically, we're still limping and now the national economy has joined us.

Our main challenge persists: to diversify the economy enough so that the auto industry doesn't make or break our future prospects *and* to increase the general education level of the adult population so that higher paying work comes to stay in Michigan.

How are we doing? Hard to say. We've been very distracted with the presidential primary farce and now the tragic intrigue of Mayor Kilpatrick's scandal threatens to become a long-term preoccupation.

I'm not the only one growing weary. The blogger Wizard Kitten remarked earlier this week:
"Sometimes blogging about politics and current events in the state of Michigan has all the charm of being repeatedly hit with a baseball bat. You try to get in a groove, accentuate the postitives, and Bam! something comes along that is so big, so tragic, that it steals all the oxygen out of the room, breaks your heart, and leaves you to pick up the pieces in some vain attempt to put your emotional Humpty back together again."
I couldn't have said it better.

Now, how is it we shall find the energy, optimism and hope to keep going? Consider this an appeal for ideas and recommendations. I want to know what the rest of you are doing to stay in it...this fight for Michigan. Can you share what motivates you with others whose enthusiasm may be waning?

Any tips for remaining audaciously, and perhaps foolishly, hopeful in Michigan?

Yours truly,
CEW

For auto industry, cheap foreign labor isn't cheap

previously posted at Michigan Messenger

Cheaper isn't necessarily cheaper when it comes to auto industry outsourcing.

In a monumental case of penny wise and pound foolish, the Detroit Three are enamored of cheap foreign labor, even as total costs frequently wipe out those savings.

"People think they buy things so cheaply. They say, `We only paid $75,000 for the part this time.' But it doesn't get accounted for that they paid another $100,000 to fix it," said a tool and die company owner who spoke on condition of anonymity. The company's clients include the Detroit Three and Tier One suppliers. In any given week, remediation of bad tooling from abroad can make up 80 percent of this company's work.

This practice is not unusual in the tool and die industry, according to Brian Sullivan, director of communications for the Tooling, Manufacturing & Technologies Association.

The Detroit Three and Tier One suppliers complain that U.S. labor costs are not competitive with cheap foreign labor and use this premise to keep supplier bids low and drive down wages for U.S. workers. Yet, the industry routinely accrues additional hidden costs doing business with China, say small manufacturers. Transportation, inventory and rectifying poor quality create additional costs that eat away at profits and make the domestic auto industry less competitive.

A dramatic case described by the tool and die company owner involved airlifting parts to an assembly plant just in the nick of time. A mere 35 minutes before an assembly line would run out of a critical part, a helicopter landed on the assembly plant's front lawn with enough parts to keep production going until a truck arrived with more.

Four days earlier, a die made in China broke in production at a stamping plant, jeopardizing the plant's ability to deliver promised parts to the auto company. The die was made from inferior materials. A Michigan-based tool and die shop saved the day by patching together the die and producing parts at very slow speed on their own presses.

The stamping company thought it had saved $35,000 by procuring the die from China, but in the end, the misadventure cost an additional $400,000 to fix the die, stay on schedule and fly parts to the auto manufacturer. The stamping company took these extraordinary measures to avoid paying the auto company $100,000 per day in the event of a shutdown. Although rectifying this situation cost the supplier, similar events also happen at the expense the Detroit Three.

"In the tooling industry, they'll say, `In China this mold costs $15,000 and in the U.S. it costs $40,000, so you need to meet the price.' They don't add in the other costs as far as shipping and quality," said Lori Schmald Moncrieff, owner of Schmald Tool and Die.

In some cases "the transportation cost and inventory cost - weeks of inventory sitting in cartons on boats and so on - that cost is greater than the labor savings even if the labor cost is zero," said David Cole, director of the Center for Automotive Research.

"We aren't competing against private entrepreneurial companies; we are competing against the Chinese government," said the company owner. Chinese companies can proffer vastly lower bids than U.S. companies because of state subsidies. U.S. manufacturers must include capital investment in their bids, while subsidized Chinese companies do not, and this results in artificially low bids.

Interestingly, Japanese manufacturers in the U.S. typically seek local, not foreign, sourcing. "The Japanese don't believe that sourcing to China is the better business model. Honda is a perfect model of a company in the tooling industry that buys tooling cheaper than any other automaker in the United States," Moncrieff said. "They believe in partnering and co-management with U.S. local domestic sources. They're doing the opposite of what the U.S. automakers are doing."

The tool and die company owner says the Japanese engage in systems-based costing while the Detroit Three practice "opportunistic buying." "There is a complete disconnect between the price and the cost because of the way our companies are fragmented. You don't see Honda and Toyota doing this. They are not interested in doing this, because they are focused on total cost."

So while the Detroit Three keep bargain hunting and driving down prices in the supplier community, they do so at the expense of developing quality. "A consistent supply chain allows you to sustain and improve quality tremendously. If you are always changing suppliers, how can you establish quality?" asked the owner.

The company owner says that Honda values continuity in its supply chain and expects that suppliers need to be profitable. In what suppliers see as a collaboration, "They want you to reduce your cost but maintain profit. They don't want to reduce their cost by decreasing our profit."

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

High tech growth in Ann Arbor

Do a dance of joy at this news: two high tech startups have announced plans to set up shop in Ann Arbor.

Sakti3, a University of Michigan spinout, headed by U-M professor Ann Marie Sastry, plans to invest $1.1 million and hire some 112 workers. The company hopes to "commercialize a manufacturing process in Ann Arbor for the development of high-power batteries that will withstand the rigors of automotive use, primarily in electric vehicles," according to the MEDC. Translation, this company could develop a lithium ion battery that would drive the Volt.

MyBuys is an online retailing firm led by U-M graduate Bob Cell. The company provides personalized product recommendations to online retailers' customers, expects to open an office in the Ann Arbor area, investing $5.4 million and hiring 250 workers.

Take that, slumping, crunching, downward spiraling economy! Hah.

Saturday, March 15, 2008

Slump and crunch -- nouns of choice for economic catastrophe

Are you getting as tired of these two words as I am? It seems economic writers either lack creativity or have collectively decided these are jargon. I'm leaning toward the first explanation, but the second could be real, since pundits and experts seem to favor these terms.

It's interesting that these both these terms are single syllable with short 'u' sounds. Slump. Crunch. Slump suggests an atypical period of poor performance as in, "The batter is suffering a slump." Crunch evokes collisions of heavy objects. Cars crunch when they hit each other. Crunch can also be the sound of breakfast cereal, or footfalls on ice-covered snow. As for the historic economic crisis of late, collision is probably on the mark.

What is colliding? Conventional wisdom lists subprime loans, trade deficit, housing bubble, falling dollar, rising energy prices, lax mortgage regulation, repeal of Glass-Steagall, and more.

But what is really colliding? Our financial system has become remote from the so-called real economy. Put another way: individual greed has overrun collective concern for each other. The desire to make a buck at the expense of others has triumphed. Nothing new under the sun, really. And this greed has enabled lots of people choosing to live beyond their means over understanding the limits that the economy has placed upon them.

Yesterday, I heard an economist proclaim that "credit is the lifeblood of our economy." Translation: the promise to pay tomorrow for something I want to day is fueling our economy.

Home Depot now has a hilarious ad campaign: "It's time to put off procrastination" with no payments for 12 months. I think it's meant to be a pun on put off, as well as to be ironic. Don't procrastinate in possessing what you want, just procrastinate in paying for it. Because as long as you charge it, we'll get our money. Deal done. Seems cynical.

So the credit crunch comes from loss of confidence that borrowers can pay back loans, which collides with the need of institutions to borrow money to make loans. Big lenders withhold from other lenders who would make sure you can "put off procrastination."

For a moment, people shake their heads, maybe splash water on their faces and say "hey wait a minute, all that equity justifying our credit/debt complex (financial system) just evaporated. How the hell are people going to pay that back?"

How indeed? Selling apples on the street corner? Probably not.

Friday, March 14, 2008

As proactive as Herbert Hoover?

In a move that makes President Herbert Hoover look proactive, the Bush administration is taking action to deal with the credit crisis.

From the New York Times:

"After months of watching a growing credit crisis made worse by steadily eroding home prices, the Bush administration responded on Thursday with the outlines of a plan that officials emphasized is meant more to prevent future crises than to address the current one."

You go, boy.

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

American Axle strike -- wide reaching, persistent, and ineffective

Although the American Axle strike has persisted into a third week and has shutdown or slowed 29 GM plants, it is not yet effective. GM has about 100 days of truck inventory and can watch from the sidelines, without intervening or tampering or nudging the UAW/American Axle talks toward closure.

GM expected truck sales to slow this year and the strike is almost doing them a favor. The company can cease production of vehicles that it can't sell anyway and can point to the action of the UAW as the cause for shutdown. It's an elegant solution for GM, as it shrugs and says "oh well."

Some have said that dealers will be the first to feel real pressure as their inventory offerings become limited. Yet, Ford and Chrysler are looking at ways to reduce the number of dealers in their pipeline. Could this be part of the GM plan as well?

The market for domestic vehicles will continue to shrink, according to the Center for Automotive Research, over the next five years. The whole system will need to shrink accordingly from parts suppliers to assembly to dealers.

So it begins, with the bold effort of the UAW at American Axle. Conventional wisdom would see that stopping production of axles would stop production of vehicles. In another day and age that would have put the UAW in a position of strength -- no axles, no cars and trucks. Now, it seems the UAW is just helping GM manage inventory.

Let's hope the American Axle workers are not striking in vain or shooting themselves in the foot.

Friday, February 1, 2008

Looking for the upside -- reader forum on Michigan's economy


Well, folks, it's a little hard to see the positive today considering these tidbits.

  • Ford may not refill its ranks
    From the Free Press: "As Ford Motor Co. begins offering voluntary buyouts and early-retirement packages to its 54,000 UAW hourly workers -- and continues trimming its salaried ranks -- CEO Alan Mulally said it's not clear that the departing workers will be replaced in these tough economic times."

  • Chrysler offers buyouts to hourly workers in Detroit
    The New York Times reports that this offer "means that nearly all hourly automotive workers in Michigan now have the option to leave their job this year. Earlier this month, the Ford Motor Company began a second round of companywide buyouts and General Motors extended buyout offers to about half of its work force."


  • We're going to need massive programs to help workers retool, retrain, and go back to school. We're going to need more emergency social services, food assistance, shelter and cash assistance to keep utilities on.

    So, here are my questions to readers for this informal survey and forum. Ponder them and then send your responses via comments. Thanks for reading.

    1. Do you know someone experiencing financial hardship right now?

    2. Is this a new situation for them? Can you describe it?

    3. Are or were they employed in the auto industry or auto parts sector?

    4. If you know people considering relocating out of the state, why are they considering leaving?

    5. Do you think most Michiganders understand the economic downturn is NOT cyclical?

    6. Do you think most Michiganders understand the economic situation as a historic shift to post-industrial economy?

    7. Do you have any advice for Michiganders having a hard time economically?

    8. What do you think can help Michigan's economy?

    Thursday, January 31, 2008

    Trickle downsizing -- auto industry turmoil wracks parts suppliers

    From a one-man office in Grand Haven, John Rickfelder sells automotive components directly to the Big Three. His employer, Los Angeles-based Judco Manufacturing, employs nearly 300 people who make electrical switches and other components. Up until two years ago those workers were employed in Los Angeles, but in order to meet price demands of the Big Three, the company moved production to Honduras. Wages there were 90 percent lower than in the United States. "I'm seeing a constant movement of component work leaving for Mexico, China, South America and Central America," Rickfelder said.

    Many auto parts suppliers are moving jobs overseas, downsizing or quitting the business altogether in response to ongoing challenges in the domestic auto market. The auto parts sector is an important part of Michigan's economy, providing 10 percent of all jobs.

    A car is more than the sum of its parts, and Michigan's automotive economy is much more than the Big Three. For every one automotive assembly job, there are about four parts supplier jobs. According to industry analysts, each assembly job also accounts for three to four additional jobs in local businesses. As the Big Three restructure, downsize and outsource, suppliers have scrambled to remain viable and competitive. Some have survived, but many have not.

    "We have a lot of consolidation going on in the supplier community. There are bankruptcies, companies going out of business, global purchasing - the turmoil here is absolutely huge," said David Cole, chairman of the Center for Automotive Research. "The cut backs and buyouts really ramped down production at the end of the year. And that is difficult for suppliers because their purchase orders and sales have been hit very, very hard."

    In the last few years, the majority of tier-one suppliers, those selling directly to the Big Three, have filed bankruptcy. Tier-two and tier-three companies, those who sell to the major suppliers, subsequently suffer the consequences of the sector's upheaval - chaos trickles down.

    The auto parts manufacturing sector accounts for 523,700 jobs or about 10 percent of total state employment in Michigan - the highest proportion of any state economy. According to the Center for Automotive Research, motor vehicle parts supplier operations contributed 145,800 direct jobs, 192,732 indirect jobs (people who work to supply the parts manufacturers) and 185,164 expenditure induced jobs (jobs created coming from consumer spending of direct and indirect employees).

    "Over a five-year period, 90 percent of the tier ones are or will be filing bankruptcy," said Laurie Schmald Moncrieff, third-generation owner of Schmald Tool & Die in Burton. As the Big Three make fewer cars, the economic and employment impact for Michigan suppliers and communities is profound.

    "If you drive down some of the heavy industrial streets in Detroit, like Groesbeck, there is one after another of small manufacturing factories for sale," said Brian Sullivan, director of sales and marketing for the Tooling, Manufacturing and Technologies Association, a national trade association representing small manufacturers. "It is like 'The Grapes of Wrath.' People are leaving and trying to find another place to make a living."

    Sullivan attributes the harsh economic climate for small manufacturers to "bad trade laws" and foreign competitors not adhering to trade agreements. Moncrieff agrees, noting: "The Chinese government, although illegal under WTO (World Trade Organization) rules and trade agreements, picks up a third of the cost of new equipment, and the Bank of China picks up a third. So somebody who owns a company in China only has to pick up a third of the cost of new equipment."

    But while keenly aware of foreign competition, Moncrieff sees the situation's complexity. Small manufacturers face higher overhead costs, and many are overleveraged. They also face increased regulatory compliance requirements. She said many companies, complacent from years of ample business, were caught off-guard by the impact of Big Three restructuring.

    "There is going to have to be a consolidation. The situation a lot of people are in is they can't afford to stay in business and they can't afford to get out," Moncrieff said.

    "What a lot of small manufacturers are doing is rather than try to sell their business because they see the handwriting on the wall, they simply close the door. They just lock the door and they go away," Sullivan said.

    But Irvin Swider, president of Future Products Corp., in Clawson, offers another model for coping with the tough environment. His company, founded 44 years ago by his father, is a tier-two tooling company that has no debt, owns all its machinery and facilities and has a corps of 65 long-term, highly skilled employees. Swider is aware of the challenges in the sector, but committed to sustaining and building his business in Michigan.

    While automotive demand is shrinking, Swider is seeking opportunities in other sectors. "The bottom line is there is too much supply for the demand right now," Swider said. "We have started diversifying into the medical sector and aerospace. We also do tooling for appliance and HVAC (heating, ventilating and air conditioning) manufacturing."

    Ultimately Swider pegs hope for his company's future to the quality of his employees: "I could not go to Shanghai and open this business. Who would I have to do the work? These are highly skilled laborers. The people are everything."

    Wednesday, January 2, 2008

    For Ann Arbor restaurateur, a long-term commitment


    Winning a stare down with adversity, restaurant owner Rob Terbush plans to stay in Michigan for the long haul.

    In 2006, when sales fell by 55 percent, some expected his Holiday's restaurant to close, but Terbush hung on. Now in his 11th year of business, the 34-year-old Michigan native sustains a long-term vision for his restaurant on Ann Arbor's busy West Stadium Boulevard.

    "Our whole goal all along has been to become a long-term staple and buy the property," Terbush said.

    Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner at prices families can afford in the current tight economy, Terbush focuses on quality, atmosphere and service to set Holiday's apart from the competition.

    "We fall into the category of fast casual. We cook meals to order, so people are willing to slow down for an extra five or 10 minutes for something fresh and hot," he said. He trains new hires in his "ABCD" program -- Above and Beyond the Call of Duty. "People can satisfy their hunger at a lot of restaurants, so we work to create a warm atmosphere with personalized service and attention." He estimates that about 200 other restaurants in Washtenaw County offer similar fare at similar prices.

    He strives to balance consistency with novelty to keep regulars coming back while also attracting new customers. "Regulars order 'the usual,' even though they are interested in new things," he said. But bringing in more customers doesn't necessarily add up to increased revenues. Terbush says that customer spending has been flat since 2004 and attributes that to the economy. "We did have growth in the number of people per day. But the average spending dropped and our net dollars went down," he said.

    Terbush's experience is consistent with assessments by the Michigan Restaurant Association, which recently forecast 3.2 percent growth for Michigan restaurant sales in 2008 - the slowest of any state. Most states see annual restaurant sales grow by 5 to 7 percent, according to Andy Deloney, vice president of public affairs with the Michigan Restaurant Association.

    The biggest challenge for Terbush came in 2006 when a road construction project lasting nearly two years stalled business. Customers had difficulty just pulling into the parking lot and by the end of the project sales were down 55 percent. Expecting business to slow during the road project, Terbush had timed a major exterior building renovation to coincide with the road construction. Although he knew business would decline during construction, he was caught off guard by just how much. With access to credit lines and other financing, Terbush made it through.

    Plans for further renovation have been put on hold until the business can stabilize from financing the downturn of 2006. Eventually Terbush wants to renovate the interior, add a patio, obtain a liquor license and purchase the building.

    In the meantime, he says people are simply spending less even in Ann Arbor, which has been sheltered from the worst of the state's economic problems. "They don't buy drinks; they have water. They don't order appetizers or desserts," he said. Working within the slim profit margins of the food service industry, Terbush soon will be raising prices to balance customers' lower spending with ever-increasing overhead costs. "The new menus are at the printer."

    In spite of the difficult economy, Terbush plans to stay in Michigan, growing his business and raising his three children. "I don't think I would live anywhere but Michigan," he said. "We have the Great Lakes, the Upper Peninsula, beautiful state lands, skiing, good fishing, a decent prevailing wage, and a high quality of life."

    Terbush's secret to making it in Michigan is facing difficulty head on and balancing personal life and work. Leave work at work. Slow down and appreciate what you have. Get perspective.

    "There are people not doing what you do, not earning what you earn and they're living just fine. You just have to step back, see what is and live."

    Friday, December 21, 2007

    December consumer confidence falls, will common sense follow?

    It is just four days before Christmas, a religious holiday and also consumer celebration of spending. Today the Reuters/University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index for December came in at 75.5. November's reading was 76.1.

    What does it mean? What can it mean?

    Consumers -- people who buy things in order to live -- are less confident about their finances and for good reason. The global financial house of cards has turned consumers' houses into poker chips. The consumer confidence index is often explained as indicating the prospects for consumer spending -- two thirds of economic activity -- without questioning the premise that unbridled consumer spending is good. Consumer spending has been enabled by an artificial inflation of residential real estate prices. Consumer spending has been a speculative excess of sorts.

    Now, reality is sinking in and consumers, who earn money presumably through productive activity, are seeing a bleak near-term future.

    Time for a little less debt-fueled spending. Time for a little reality-based home economics. A house is a home if you can make the mortgage payments. And you can make the mortgage payments if you resist buying cheap junk you don't actually need. Go for it. Make a new year's resolution to spend less than you earn.

    It's okay. You, the consumer, are not responsible for sustaining the economy while slitting your own pockets.

    Stabenow law offers debt help but foreclosure crisis rages on

    U.S. Sen. Debbie Stabenow's Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act has now been signed into law. The Michigan Democrat's legislation frees individuals from paying income tax when they have had a part of their mortgage loan forgiven or have been forced to foreclose. It is a measure to remove the insult of additional taxes after the injury of foreclosure.

    Even with this legislation, there is more work ahead to help borrowers stay in their homes, keep credit affordable and stave off a recession. There is plenty of blame to go around in Michigan's foreclosure crisis and not all of it in Michigan. Politicians are scrambling to respond to a crisis that was years in the making and could have been prevented through sensible regulation and appropriate oversight. Other recent actions include:
      • The Bush Administration announced an entirely voluntary plan for mortgage servicers to consider instead of outright foreclosure when borrowers fall behind on payments.

      • The Federal Reserve Bank has approved a set of rules that resemble pre-1980 lending practices - that require evidence of borrowers' income and ability to repay loans and full disclosure of the terms of a loan to borrowers before closing the deal.

      • Congress is considering legislation that would allow the Federal Housing Authority to refinance sub-prime loans due to reset at higher interest rates. The FHA would reduce down-payment requirements and increase loan amounts to accommodate the loans.

      • The Michigan Legislature is considering a sheaf of bills that would require licensing for loan officers and prohibit predatory lending practices.

      • Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox last week sponsored a foreclosure prevention forum at Cobo Center that attracted thousands of borrowers behind on their mortgage payments.

    Michigan has recorded over 135,000 foreclosure filings this year. The Detroit area ranked second highest in the third quarter for the rate of households in foreclosure -- one out of every 33 households. Wednesday, RealtyTrac announced that nationally 201,950 foreclosure filings were reported last month, compared with 120,334 in November 2006. Nevada, Florida and Ohio had the highest rates of increase over the year.

    While the situation in Michigan is not unique, it is exacerbated by our declining manufacturing economy. Here are some of the ingredients that went into making Michigan's mortgage mess:

      • Repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act in 1999. In 1933, this federal act was created to separate investment and commercial banking activities in order to prevent the speculative excesses of the type that preceded the Great Depression. Sixty-six years later, the walls protecting mortgages from becoming fodder for financial speculation finally came down.

      • Not enough mortgage examiners. The Michigan Office of Financial and Insurance Services (OFIS) is responsible for regulating the mortgage industry in Michigan. OFIS has an insufficient number of examiners - 12 to regulate over 2,800 companies making mortgages.

      • Mortgage loan officers in Michigan are not licensed. Nor does the state require background checks. Convicted criminals can become loan officers.

      • Inadequate consumer education. At the epicenter of the foreclosure crisis, Detroit HOPE, a coalition of lenders and consumer advocates, was formed in 2005 to reduce foreclosures in the metro area. In 2007, by September, the group had only held three foreclosure-prevention workshops. Only about 75 people attended each seminar.

      • Unethical, but legal, practices. Offering adjustable-rate mortgages to sub-prime borrowers is not illegal. Lax federal and state regulation has permitted giving loans without verifying income or ability to repay.

      • Unclear jurisdiction. According to the Conference of State Bank Supervisors, matters of jurisdiction are still being worked out between the states and the federal government in the courts. This April, in Watters v. Wachovia, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that state-chartered subsidiaries of national banks are exempt from state regulation. OFIS Commissioner Linda A. Watters had advocated for state regulation of state-chartered subsidiaries. Numerous organizations filed amicus briefs, as well as every state attorney general in the nation including Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico.

    Wednesday, December 19, 2007

    Michigan Restaurants Suffering

    cross-posted at Michigan Messenger
    The state's restaurants are facing belt-tightening in 2008.

    The Michigan Restaurant Association has forecast growth of only 3.2 percent for 2008, down a half percent from the 2007 forecast. The modest growth rate places Michigan's food service industry dead last in the country in growth for the second year in a row.

    "The industry is certainly struggling here," said Andy Deloney, vice president of public affairs with the Michigan Restaurant Association. He said that most states see restaurant sales grow by 5 to 7 percent annually.

    As the state economy goes, so goes the food service industry. "It's not news to anybody what the state of the Michigan economy is. People just do not have as much money in their pockets anymore," Deloney said. In addition to the nation's highest unemployment, people who do have work are experiencing periodic layoffs and less overtime.

    Michigan's economic stress affects all sectors of the food and beverage industry. "Some people think fine dining is immune to recession because the people who are still going there are the ones who have money," Deloney said. "But don't forget about the ones who would go out to celebrate an anniversary or promotion. There are fewer promotions now."

    During Michigan's extended economic slump, restaurant profit margins have been extremely slim, making it increasingly difficult for them to stay in business. "If you are doing 2 percent, you are doing well," Deloney said. "There have been a number of restaurants this year that have closed due to the economy."

    Even long-standing establishments are calling it quits. The Embers in Mt. Pleasant closed its doors this summer after nearly 50 years in business. After a run of almost 80 years, the Fox and Hounds in Bloomfield Hills also closed this summer.

    Michigan's statewide restaurant sales in 2006 were $12.3 billion. The association projected $12.8 billion for 2007, which has been borne out by business this year. The forecast for 2008 is $13.1 billion in sales.

    "Folks have been waiting for a couple of years for a turnaround to come, and they are running out of gas. They are trying to pinch as many pennies as they can," Deloney said.

    Modestly priced eateries catering to the needs of busy families are still holding their ground. "One segment doing well right now is 'fast casual.' Places like sandwich shops are providing what people are demanding," he said. Innovations like curbside pickup and phone-ahead ordering help restaurants stay competitive.

    Saturday, December 15, 2007

    Divesting from Sudan, Michigan style

    Crossposted at Michigan Messenger
    Is divestment a strategy to combat genocide in far away places or a tool to fight terrorism? Is it a matter of homeland security or an assertion of social conscience in a global community?


    Michigan's House and Senate are working on divestment legislation, but differences in approach and philosophy have created conflicting results that need to be reconciled before any legislation can be enacted. One side favors a sweeping anti-terrorism model, the other a focused strategy targeting genocide in Darfur. In spite of their differences, both sides expect to come to agreement and pass legislation in January after the holiday recess.


    Some in the Senate support a broad anti-terrorism approach aimed at all countries on the U.S. State Department list of "state sponsors of terrorism." "We shouldn't be investing Michigan dollars in countries who intend to hurt us or are our enemies or who import terrorism," said Sen. Valde Garcia (Rep. Dist. 22) a member of the Homeland Security and Emerging Technologies Committee, which in October took up review of Sen. Cameron Brown's (Rep. Dist. 16) "Divestment from Terror Act." That committee met Tuesday to consider changes to several laws that would be affected by Brown's legislation.


    Others prefer a highly specific divestment strategy focusing on a narrow list of companies in a single country. Legislation sponsored by Rep. Alma Smith (Dem. Dist. 54) follows the targeted divestment approach adopted by 54 universities and 15 states, and is based on the work of the Genocide Intervention Network. "In contrast to other divestiture legislation, this bill, and this effort to bring an end to the genocide in Darfur, is a about taking a moral and ethical stand on perhaps the greatest humanitarian issue facing the world today," Smith said. "It is not about politics or social posturing. Simply put, it is about doing the right thing."

    The state of Michigan has engaged in a divestment campaign once before. From 1979 to 1988 the state passed three acts divesting state funds from South Africa in protest of apartheid, which had divided that country by race since 1948. Divestment by states, colleges and universities is credited with catalyzing change in South Africa. Michigan ended its South African divestment in 1993, when South African leaders arrived at an agreement to create a Government of National Unity -- a bridge to democratic elections. This precedent inspires current efforts to make change in Sudan.


    Brown's legislation seeks to divest from Cuba, North Korea, Syria, Iran, and Sudan -- the complete State Department list of "state sponsors of terrorism." Brown's legislative director Kendra Butters says state pension funds and other investments would be examined to determine if their money is invested in "scrutinized companies" -- those doing business with any state sponsor of terrorism. Companies would be notified that they have to end their business relationship with the country in question. If they do not, "state dollars will be pulled out and then the fiduciary will have to reinvest in another company."


    Critics of Brown's legislation say it is so broad that it will have unintended negative consequences on economic, social and political conditions in Sudan. They say it has the potential to drive out businesses that are making a positive difference in the country.


    Butters defends the legislation, saying it provides a humanitarian exemption. "We have defined a 'social development company,' which exempts products that are helpful to the people -- things like agricultural supplies, food, medicine and other consumer products. These things are exempted," she said.


    Smith contends that Sudanese divestment should be a stand-alone bill. Proponents of her bill say this narrow focus ensures positive change in the country, not just the meting out of economic punishment. The House legislation "only targets companies in Sudan and specific sectors that are deeply problematic. It encourages them to adopt responsible business plans instead of leave the country," said Scott Wisor, senior field organizer for the Sudan Divestment Task Force.


    Another weakness of Brown's approach, say critics, is that it could be struck down as unconstitutional -- a state foray into foreign policy, something forbidden by the U.S. Constitution. Basing the legislation on a list of countries and implementing a single procedure for those countries puts Michigan's policy at odds with U.S. State Department foreign policy, which varies by country. "Unless you make sure every component of state legislation is consistent with federal guidance on the issue you run the risk of having an unconstitutional piece of legislation," Wisor said.


    In the past three years many states have initiated divestiture from Sudan. All successfully enacted state divestment legislation has been specific to a single country -- Sudan or Iran -- not the entire State Department list. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures only a few states -- Georgia, Florida, Missouri, New Jersey, Oklahoma -- have considered divestment legislation based on the State Department list of "state sponsors of terrorism."


    Sen. Hansen Clarke (Dem. Dist. 1), who introduced legislation to divest from Sudan months ago, has another bill incorporated in the Republican anti-terrorism divestment package. His pragmatic perspective may represent hope for compromise in the coming weeks. "I don't think taxpayer dollars should be used to kill innocent people in the Sudan. The Republicans are taking a broader approach, but essentially those bills would do the same thing, so I would support their effort," Clarke said.


    He hopes to help bring forth compromise and expects legislation to be passed in the House and Senate in January. "I believe we'll have a law to urge the state to divest money from businesses supporting the Sudanese government. I am a Democrat, but I don't care about the politics on this. I want to send a statement strongly that taxpayers' money should not fund genocide anywhere around the world," Clarke said.


    (Photo credit: Economist, print edition August 2, 2007)

    Tuesday, December 11, 2007

    Slamming workers for having a history

    Nolan Finley wrote this week about what he considers the stupidity of the Michigan public.

    Finley says a recent EPIC MRA poll about public education and preparing students for the future finds that "Forty-six percent said the schools should train students for jobs they can get with a high school degree, while 41 percent said college preparation should be the mission."

    Is it really so bad to wish that a publicly provided education could equip citizens for meaningful work with a living wage?

    According to pollster Ed Sarpolous, Michigan residents still identify with a manufacturing culture and are not convinced that a college education is necessary to meet their employment needs. This should come as no surprise. For generations, factory work has provided a comfortable, middle-class standard of living to Michigan citizens. People with that perspective have been shaped by the experience of their parents, grand parents and great grand parents. This world view and narrative span generations not fiscal quarters. This is about people and places and history, not shareholders and quarterly profits and global capital movement.

    Finley concludes that people in Michigan are stupid and lazy. He suggests a new strategy for promoting higher education among disadvantaged workers for whom he has contempt.

    "Create an appetite for the jobs, and maybe job seekers will get off their backsides and get themselves some skills," writes Finley blaming the unemployed for not having work.

    Here's another possibility: given the economic stresses befalling the blue-collar, Michigan middle-class maybe they are unwilling to go into debt again to get a college degree that may not allow them to pay back student loans. Maybe these folks are not ready to mortgage their future earning potential. Indeed they are still watching their nest eggs shrivel as real estate values collapse.

    Finley should read the Michigan League for Human Services recent report, The Changing Face of Poverty in Michigan, which documents stagnating wages, rising costs, increasing foreclosures, and less access to health coverage.

    Perhaps the EPIC MRA poll reveals skepticism about debt, pain from real economic stress and a resistance to acquiesce to globalization? Instead of blaming workers for wanting continuity of their family history and saying we need to better market higher education, Finley should examine cost barriers to higher education in an economy where poverty is increasing. If the unemployed are deciding between medicine and food, college tuition is probably not on their radar.

    Wednesday, December 5, 2007

    "You have to keep changing" -- Sondra O'Donnell on small business

    Yoga practitioner Sondra O'Donnell is a small-business success who shows the power of starting where you are and building on what you know. Three years ago she opened Sun Moon Yoga Studio in Ann Arbor, a university town with almost as many yoga studios as coffee shops. With nearly 20 years experience practicing and teaching yoga, O'Donnell had a solid client base, understood her field and was ready to create her own studio.

    She did just that and succeeded. O'Donnell has proven herself  in business and warns of the hardships of a start-up. "Small-business owners work hard. It's quite a juggle. You have to do everything, and you don't know what is going to come in."

    Finding a niche bolstered O'Donnell's staying power in Michigan's struggling economy and in Ann Arbor's competitive yoga market. She offers the only teacher certification program in Ann Arbor. "My main goal has been to do teacher certification. That is really what my heart and soul are in," she said. Her students come from as far as Grand Rapids and Howell for the certification program.

    O'Donnell stresses that businesses and the people who run them must be responsive to changes around them. "You have to keep creating and innovating. You can't sit and look at how things were; you have to keep changing." She has done that by creating classes to meet student demand and interest.

    Her own family had to grapple with changes wrought by the declining domestic auto industry. Growing up in the downriver Detroit area, O'Donnell was aware of the auto industry as the lifeblood of Michigan's economy. Five years ago, after 30 years in business, her father's small auto-parts-packaging company was bought out by a larger competitor.

    Bad economic news hits us daily in Michigan, and it is easy to feel demoralized. The mainstream media present economic news principally in terms of multinationals, yet millions of people across the country are self-employed or own small businesses. These small and micro-businesses strengthen local communities and affirm the human scale of economy as a path to a successful and satisfying life.

    In 2006 about 10 percent of Michigan's work force was self-employed - 480,000 people in a work force of 5 million. The self-employed account for more than half of the state's 849,500 small businesses, according to U.S. Small Business Administration data.

    O'Donnell advises people starting small businesses to work within their means and keep expenses low. "I didn't take out a single loan. We have kept the costs to a minimum. I got a lot of building materials from the Re-use Center," she said.

    In fact O'Donnell single-handedly transformed the building she rents from a warehouse into a welcoming yoga studio -- installing a cork floor, insulation, drywall, lighting and more on her own at night after her children were asleep. "I would come here at 9 p.m. and work until 4 in the morning," she said. "The next day, I'd have to make sure the tools were put away before teaching classes."

    If she needs to expand the business, her vision is to take the training program worldwide -- teaching on location around the globe. She is currently developing a second portion to her certification training for this purpose.

    O'Donnell attributes her business resilience to her yoga practice and knowledge of the sutras, sacred Hindu texts. "What gets me through is nonattachment to the studio. I just take it as it is today, this moment, without expectations," she said.

    Advising a balanced perspective for business owners, she said: "The bottom line is if you are so engrossed and attached that the business becomes everything you are, you are going to go crazy. You have to let the business be what it is."

    Helping students find balance in the midst of difficulty is at the heart of O'Donnell's teaching. "We take our stress into our bodies and see ourselves as caged in our current situation. If we can create a sense of peaceful strength, we find a balance between release and strength."

    She empowers students by helping them find their inherent wholeness. "People don't always want to hear that yoga is not about fixing you. As teachers we come here to teach you that you have the tools inside you. You are fixed; you just don't realize it."

    Thursday, November 15, 2007

    Financialization brought you the "subprime crisis"

    Banks may lose $400 billion in bad investments relating to the U.S. subprime market. (source)

    That's the bank side of the story. What about people in houses? What will they lose? How many children will be affected? How many families' financial prospects dashed? How many made homeless?

    Financialization sits at the center of the crisis, which is completely man-made.

    Acquaint yourself with this shift of priorities from the real sector (where a house is a house) to the financial sector (where a house spawns a securitized debt instrument) by reading "Financialization: What It Is and Why It Matters," by economics professor Thomas Palley, UMass Amherst.

    From the abstract?
    "Financialization is a process whereby financial markets, financial institutions and financial elites gain greater influence over economic policy and economic outcomes. Financialization transforms the functioning of economic system at both the macro and micro levels. Its principal impacts are to (1) elevate the significance of the financial sector relative to the real sector; (2) transfer income from the real sector to the financial sector; and (3) increase income inequality and contribute to wage stagnation. There are reasons to believe that financialization may render the economy prone to risk of debt-deflation and prolonged recession."

    Happy reading, it is not. Essential reading? Yes.

    Monday, November 12, 2007

    Cleaning house in Michigan


    I’m a fan of Clean House, a low budget home make-over show on the Style Network. Reruns play every morning while I drink coffee, open my eyes to the day and scan the news online. Niecy Nash, diva hostess, implores people to let go of their “foolishness.” She charms them to release precious junk – flamingos, surf boards snapped in two, chipped coffee mugs, unopened wedding gifts – in return for clarity, order and space.

    It’s the same script every show: cheerful make-over team intervenes with pathologically messy family; everyone cleans house, has yard sale; family gets new style and second chance; gratitude and smiles all around. No matter how many times I see these episodes, I’m comforted by the resolution of someone else’s mess, their relief and freedom from bondage to stuff and the past.

    Scanning the news of Michigan’s economy and politics in Lansing also feels like watching reruns, but without the catharsis of a neat and tidy resolution and the peace of knowing it’s not my mess. If you live in Michigan, it is your mess and these are your reruns. Your family’s prospects grow in the economic present. Heavy industrial clutter, obsolete beliefs, and careers snapped in two dog us. The make-over team in Lansing lacks unified leadership and has too many designers.

    On Clean House, folks part with clutter at fire sale prices. They paid full retail, but they’ll take tag sale premium for the sake of a new beginning. That’s the choice facing homeowners trying to sell in Michigan right now. That’s the choice for workers considering buyouts. And college graduates looking for work.

    Since we lack a designer and unified vision, we have to be responsible for our choices and futures. No one will bail us out of this and we don’t have the time to wait for new leadership. Instead of following every Lansing rerun and playing bit parts, citizens need to write a new script and claim the lead role. Be sure to vote. Write letters. Take action in the interest of your family, community and future. Start at your kitchen table and work out from there. And think about taking a mainstream media holiday – you’ll only be missing reruns!